This is all happening so fast! Within the last hour, Democratic gubernatorial candidate – and former Republican governor – Charlie Crist filed an amicus brief in the Pareto v. Ruvin case in Miami-Dade County. NOT SURPRISING! Crist has been pretty solid in his support for equality this go 'round, even speaking at a Pride event in St. Petersburg yesterday
. And though on the surface Crist's filing seems to just be a nudge of support for the amicus briefs filed by the cities of Orlando and Miami Beach
– in which the economic and psychological benefits of equality are championed – coming in advance of the July 2 hearing for summary judgment, it's actually a bit more than that. Rather than resting on the laurels of defending the people's stupid 2008 vote to write the marriage ban into the state's constitution like Attorney General Pam Bondi (Bondi joined the case this week when she realized that there would be no serious defense of the indefensible)
, Crist presents a fairly serious mea culpa on the issue. To wit:
As a former Governor, Attorney General and Commissioner of Education for the State of Florida who has opposed extending full marriage equality to gay and lesbian families in the past, and, in fact, supported the constitutional amendment challenged here, Charlie Crist is in a unique position to provide this Court with argument as to why the political process that produced Florida’s discriminatory marriage laws is not due the normal deference that Courts should apply to actions of the people in enacting amendments to the Florida constitution and to their representatives in enacting Florida law. The simple reason is that Florida’s same-sex marriage law was grounded in unlawful discrimination when it was enacted in 1977, and the purported evidence and arguments that seemed to support the similar constitutional amendment in 2008 have been discredited both by science and experience. The evidence now known to be true is that discriminatory marriage laws – like discrimination by government in any form – undermine effective governance. Such laws produce a discrimination that is incompatible with the constitutional commitment to equal treatment under the law.
SCIENCE AND EXPERIENCE, YOU GUYS!!!! Anyway, the whole eating of crow is on display below. Bravo, Charlie, at least on this issue. The times are indeed changing.
Equality Florida Action – one of the suing parties – issued the following statement about Crist's support.
Former Florida Governor Charlie Crist Files Legal Brief In Support of Marriage Equality
(June 27, 2014) – Former Florida Governor Charlie Crist has filed an amicus brief today in support of the marriage equality lawsuit Pareto v. Ruvin, which is set for a hearing on July 2 before Judge Sarah Zabel in the Eleventh Judicial Circuit Court in Miami. (www.eqfl.org/crist)
Judge Zabel will hear from attorneys who filed a lawsuit in January on behalf of six same-sex couples and Equality Florida Institute. The lawsuit argues that Florida’s laws barring same-sex couples from marriage violate the United States Constitution by denying them the legal protections and equal dignity that having the freedom to marry provides.
An amicus brief, literally translated from Latin as a “friend of the court,” is a brief that may be filed by someone who is not a party to the litigation, but who believes that the court's decision may affect its interest.
"As former Governor, and as someone who previously supported this measure, Charlie Crist's words matter a great deal,” said Nadine Smith, CEO of Equality Florida. “He has taken the same journey the majority of Floridians have taken in realizing that this ban serves no purpose but to disparage and discriminate against gay couples and our children."
In the brief, Crist stated that as a former Governor and Attorney General who previously supported the ban, he is in a unique position to provide the court a perspective on why it is wrong, harmful to Florida and harmful to gay couples and children who are denied the protections only marriage provides.
Crist is among the fast growing majority of Floridians, 57% currently, who have come to support full marriage equality.
In filing, he joins the Mayors of Orlando and Miami Beach, who also filed amicus briefs earlier this week on behalf of their cities including arguments on how lifting the ban alleviates hardships for same-sex couples and provides numerous benefits for citizens and employees to live in a non-discriminatory environment.
In a major breakthrough nationally yesterday, the nation celebrated marriage equality victories in Indiana and Utah, which included the US 10th Circuit Court, with NCLR’s Shannon Minter as lead counsel. Minter is also a lead counsel in Pareto v. Ruvin.
Statement from Charlie Crist:
“In just the last six years, our society has evolved and moved past the prejudices rooted in our past. Further, science has uniformly reached the conclusion that heterosexual marriages are just as valued and revered as they have ever been; and children raised by gay and lesbian parents fare just as well as kids raised in straight families.
“Thus, with the arc of history now, in fact, bending toward justice, this issue of marriage equality will almost certainly not even be an issue for the children and grandchildren of this State. But it is still the duty of those in the present to recognize that the legitimacy of government depends upon its willingness to fairly, transparently, and equitably administer the law. That goal is frustrated by denying an entire class of citizens equality in the institution of marriage simply because of who they are and whom they love.”
To read the the amicus brief, click www.eqfl.org/crist